You’re Optimizing for the Wrong Customer
⚠️There’s a quiet leak inside a lot of high-performing accounts, Meta embeds AI in ads as YouTube redefines engagement, and more!
Howdy Readers 🥰
In this newsletter, you’ll find:
🤳 You’re Optimizing for the Wrong Customer
🤖 Meta Embeds AI in Ads as YouTube Redefines Engagement
🏆 Ad of the Day
If you’re new to ScaleUP then a hearty welcome to you, you’ve reached the right place along with 50k+ CEOs, CMOS, and marketers. Let’s get into it, shall we? Oh! Before you forget, if someone forwarded this newsletter to you, don't forget to subscribe to our newsletter so you never miss out!
Together with Syncly
What They Say About You Isn’t in Your Dashboard
In 2026, one video can tank a brand before your team even sees it. And most listening tools are blind to it. They track text while the real damage or demand is happening inside the video.
You’re probably missing:
Spoken Mentions: People say your name without ever typing it, so it never hits your dashboard.
Untagged Endorsements: Creators push your product, and you never see it.
Negative PR: By the time it shows up in comments, you’re already behind the narrative.
Syncly Social fixes this by doing what every text-based tool cannot.
True video listening: See every brand moment on TikTok, IG, and YouTube, tagged or not.
Influencer discovery: Find creators already proving they can move your audience.
Competitive intel: Spot the content driving your competitors’ momentum early.
Team at Tiffany & Co, Samsung, and Adidas rely on Syncly Social because it catches the brand mentions that traditional tools never pick up.
Book a call today and see exactly what Syncly Social would uncover for your brand!
🤳 You’re Optimizing for the Wrong Customer
There’s a quiet leak inside a lot of high-performing accounts.
The issue isn’t traffic quality or, creative fatigue. It’s who you’re optimizing for.
Most teams optimize for the average customer because dashboards default to averages. Blended ROAS. Overall CVR. Total AOV. That middle number feels safe. But the average customer rarely drives the business.
In many brands, a small percentage of buyers generate a disproportionate share of contribution profit. They reorder faster. They refund less. They don’t need a discount every time. Yet your ads, offers, and hooks are engineered to convert the broad middle.
Here’s what breaks.
When you chase the average, your messaging flattens. Hooks become generic. Offers skew discount-heavy to appeal widely. You end up attracting more transactional buyers who convert once and disappear. Volume increases. Economic durability weakens.
It’s not that your creative isn’t working. It’s that it’s working for the wrong cohort.
The shift is simple but uncomfortable.
Stop asking, “Which ad converts best?”
Start asking, “Which first-touch angle produces the highest 90-day value?”
Segment customers by their first interaction. Track repeat rate, refund rate, and margin contribution by entry point. You’ll often find that the ad with lower CTR produces customers who spend significantly more over time.
That’s not a weak ad. That’s a high-leverage one.
If pulling that data feels messy, this is where something like Thesys helps. You can connect your store data and simply ask, “Show LTV by first-touch creative,” and get a clear visual answer instead of building another dashboard. You can claim $10 free credits here
The real unlock is strategic, not technical.
When you optimize for the average, you maximize short-term conversion. When you optimize for the concentrated few, you build long-term economics.
And long-term economics is what actually scales.
🤖 Meta Embeds AI in Ads as YouTube Redefines Engagement
Two platform updates are forcing marketers to rethink both execution and format. Meta is pushing AI deeper into Ads Manager, while new YouTube data challenges assumptions about optimal video length. Both shifts affect planning, workflow, and performance measurement.
The Breakdown:
Meta has rolled Manus AI into Ads Manager through the Tools section, with some advertisers now seeing in-stream prompts, helping with reporting, audience research, and handling repetitive campaign tasks more efficiently within one workflow.
Meta acquired Manus last month and is expanding its visibility across ad accounts. The integration connects AI agents directly to advertiser workflows.
📺 YouTube’s Engagement Sweet Spot
Videos between 1 and 3 minutes lead with a 2.5% engagement rate. Clips under 30 seconds average 1%, while videos over 10 minutes reach about 1.7%. Engagement does not rise or fall evenly with runtime.
Videos in the 3 to 5 minute range perform worst at 0.8%. They are often too long for casual viewing but lack the depth of long-form storytelling. Trimming length alone does not guarantee performance.
Marketers must optimize for value density, not just brevity. Short-form boosts reach but not always engagement, while longer formats raise costs without guaranteed return. Audience intent drives watch time. Meanwhile, Manus may streamline workflows, unlocking new efficiencies inside campaign execution.
🏆 Ad of the Day
What Works:
1. They Sell the Aesthetic, Not the Product - This isn’t about nail durability or polish formula. It’s about a vibe. “The sweetest way to shine” makes the look feel playful and feminine before you even zoom in.
2. Food Imagery Does Emotional Work - Donuts and coffee aren’t random. They make the “sugar-glazed” name feel literal, almost edible, which makes the finish feel glossy and indulgent.
3. This is a Trend Extension Play - “Elevated take on our bestselling shape” signals evolution, not overhaul. It invites existing fans to upgrade without feeling like they’re abandoning what they liked.
If you’re selling beauty, anchor it in a mood. Tie the product to a lifestyle scene so people want the feeling, not just the finish.
Advertise with Us
Wanna put out your message in front of over 50,000 best marketers and decision makers?
We are concerned about everything DTC and its winning strategies. If you liked what you read, why not join the 50k+ marketers from 13k+ DTC brands who have already subscribed? Just follow this.
At ScaleUP, we care about our readers and want to provide the best possible experience. That's why we always look for ways to improve our content and connect with our audience. If you'd like to stay in touch, be sure to follow us EVERYWHERE🥰
Thanks for your support :) We'll be back again with more such content 🥳