The Stable Workhorse Ads
đ¨ Why a DTC accountâs most valuable ads are never the sexy ones, What creators expect from brands, and more!
Howdy Readers đĽ°Â
In this newsletter, youâll find:
đ¨ The âStable Workhorseâ Theory: Why a DTC Accountâs Most Valuable Ads Are Never the Sexy Ones
đŁ What Creators Expect From Platforms and Brands in 2025
đ Ad of the Day
If youâre new to ScaleUP then a hearty welcome to you, youâve reached the right place along with 50k+ CEOs, CMOS, and marketers. Letâs get into it, shall we? Oh! Before you forget, if someone forwarded this newsletter to you, don't forget to subscribe to our newsletter so you never miss out!
Together with Lindy
Meet the AI That Actually Gets Work Done
Ever wish ChatGPT could actually do the work, not just talk about it?
Thatâs Lindy, your 24/7 AI employee that builds, runs, and delivers without a single line of code. Just describe what you need, and Lindy handles the rest, from automating leads to managing weekly reports while you focus on growth.
Create booking platforms and lead follow-ups in minutes
Automate reporting, sales, and support across your stack
Reclaim 10+ hours a week without adding headcount
Top operators call Lindy their âAI team that never sleeps,â driving faster turnarounds, fewer errors, and more profitable weeks.
Picture waking up to new leads handled, reports ready, and no missed tasks, all without hiring a single person.
Claim $20 in free credits and automate your first workflow today!
đ¨ The âStable Workhorseâ Theory: Why a DTC Accountâs Most Valuable Ads Are Never the Sexy Ones
Across hundreds of DTC accounts, one recurring pattern keeps resurfacing:
The ads that generate the most consistent profit are rarely the viral, polished, or high-production winners. They are the quiet performers, the ads that neither dominate dashboards nor die under pressure.
These are the âworkhorse adsâ: creative pieces that canât scale aggressively, yet outperform every other asset in long-term contribution.
Why Workhorse Ads Matter More Than Ever in 2025
Metaâs ecosystem has shifted. Signal loss, platform noise, and faster fatigue cycles have created a world where very few ads can maintain efficiency beyond a narrow budget range.
Instead of scaling to $5k/day like in 2020, many of todayâs strongest ads peak at $150â$300/day.
Push them any further and CPAs spike instantly. This has changed the physics of paid social. Single-hero-ad scaling is no longer a reliable tactic. The accounts that maintain stability today have one defining trait:
A portfolio of 3â7 workhorse ads running quietly at profitable, low budgets, acting as the âfoundation layerâ beneath all scaling activity.
How Workhorse Ads Are Identified (The Four Operational Flags)
Workhorses tend to reveal themselves through a specific behavioral signature:
1ď¸âŁ Low volatility across 7â14-day cycles: Their CPAs remain steady even when the broader market fluctuates.
2ď¸âŁ Budget ceilings between $100â$300/day: They collapse when pushed higher, but remain highly efficient at small volumes.
3ď¸âŁ Failure to win head-to-head creative tests: They donât shine in structured testing frameworks, yet outperform over months of real-world delivery.
4ď¸âŁ Superior downstream customer quality: Workhorses often generate cohorts with higher LTV and lower churn, despite unimpressive CTRs.
This pattern makes them counterintuitive: they rarely appear exciting in the short term⌠but they consistently contribute the healthiest revenue in the long term.
Why Workhorses Function as Account Stabilizers
In high-velocity creative environments, workhorse ads serve as operational ballast. They keep the account anchored while testing and scaling introduces volatility.
When scaling campaigns experience performance swings, especially common with novel creatives, workhorses:
Maintain baseline profitable spend
Reduce blended CPA spikes
Normalize account-level volatility
Extend the lifespan of scaling experiments
Prevent overreactions or premature shutdowns
Many advertisers unknowingly delete these assets because they âdonât win tests.â
But their purpose is not to win. Their purpose is to keep the account stable enough for innovation to happen.
How Workhorses Protect Scaling Campaigns
In accounts where workhorses run consistently:
ROAS cliffs become softer
Revenue becomes more predictable
Cashflow planning becomes easier
Creative testing becomes less risky
High-budget scale moves become safer
Workhorses, therefore, act like financial shock absorbers. They give breathing room for new creative concepts to find traction, something impossible in a purely high-volatility account.
Workhorse ads donât dominate dashboards. They simply refuse to die.
Scalable growth isnât driven by isolated hero ads, itâs driven by creative portfolios where stable low-budget performers form the safety net beneath bolder scaling plays. Brands that build this foundation consistently outperform brands relying on single-ad winners.
đŁ What Creators Expect From Platforms and Brands in 2025
Snapchat, Publicis Media, and Ipsos surveyed 1,120 creators across six markets to understand how they choose platforms, brands, and communities as the creator economy heads toward 1.1T by 2032, with over 200M creators worldwide shaping content behavior.
The Breakdown:
1. Platform Comfort & Tools - Creators are 1.3x more likely to post daily-life content on Snapchat, with 42 percent tailoring per platform, 49% posting uniformly, and 9% mixing approaches.
2. Partnership Expectations Creators choose brands based on quality, value alignment, communication, and transparency, with 45% of 100K plus creators wanting long-term partnerships and most outreach coming via social at 54%, DMs at 45%, and email at 44%.
3. Representation Impact - Multicultural consumers want brands to represent people like them at 70% and authentically represent diverse groups at 67%, which directly translates into action as 53% buy more from diverse brands and 51% pay more when represented.
4. AR Expression & Social Values - Self-expression matters with 64 percent using AR, 59% saying AR Lenses help express identity, and 62% liking branded Lenses, while 67% want brands to speak on issues from data privacy to mental health, and nearly a third want proof of community impact.
Creators expect platform-specific comfort, creative tools, and long-term brand alignment while multicultural consumers demand accurate representation, expressive AR formats, and real action on issues, leading brands that meet these expectations to gain stronger trust, better relevance, and higher purchase intent.
đ Ad of the Day
What works:
1) Harmony of chaos and calm - The frame celebrates mess without showing it, spilled snacks and a dog on the rug, yet everything feels serene. This balance disarms guilt and reframes imperfection as beauty.
2) Language of permission, not control - âLet kids be kids. Let dogs be dogs.â subtly releases the viewer from constant vigilance. The copy repositions cleaning as emotional freedom, not duty, a cognitive reframe that builds deep trust.
3) Visual storytelling of safety - The childâs prone posture, dogâs calm presence, and warm neutral palette all communicate psychological safety. The image functions as subconscious validation rather than aspiration; the brand becomes reassurance.
This ad wins because it sells peace of mind disguised as a rug. Every visual and word dissolves friction; itâs not about stain resistance, itâs about emotional permission to live fully without apology.
Advertise with Us
Wanna put out your message in front of over 50,000 best marketers and decision makers?
We are concerned about everything DTC and its winning strategies. If you liked what you read, why not join the 50k+ marketers from 13k+ DTC brands who have already subscribed? Just follow this.
At ScaleUP, we care about our readers and want to provide the best possible experience. That's why we always look for ways to improve our content and connect with our audience. If you'd like to stay in touch, be sure to follow us EVERYWHEREđĽ°
Thanks for your support :) We'll be back again with more such content đĽł