Stop Testing Like a Gambler
đď¸ The algorithmâs the dealer, and it already knows your tells, Media buyer index of the week, and more!
Howdy Readers đĽ°Â
In this newsletter, youâll find:
đď¸ Creative Ops for 10Ă Input: Stop testing like a Gambler
đ Ad market shakeup: CPC, CAC, and ROAS at a Glance
đ Ad of the Day
If youâre new to ScaleUP then a hearty welcome to you, youâve reached the right place along with 50k+ CEOs, CMOS, and marketers. Letâs get into it, shall we? Oh! Before you forget, if someone forwarded this newsletter to you, don't forget to subscribe to our newsletter so you never miss out!
đď¸ Creative Ops for 10Ă Input: Stop Testing Like a Gambler
Testing isnât poker anymore. The algorithm is the dealer, and it already knows your tells. Every unstructured test bleeds margin, because chaos doesnât teach, it just burns.
Walk into BFCM without a creative system, and youâre scaling noise, not signal. You donât need âmore ads.â You need input velocity and infrastructure that multiply learnings per dollar, not just impressions per ad.
đ§ Build Like a SaaS Team, Not a Content Farm
Creative orgs winning BFCM look more like product teams than TikTok studios. Sprints. Systems. Inputs. Postmortems.
They ship learning cycles, not lucky hits.
Hereâs what their stack looks like:
â 25+ new ads/month per offer
â Script + hook libraries
â Claim tagging by outcome tier
â Modular UGC-ready assets
â Bulk scoring and feedback loops
Every ad is a release. Every release attacks friction. Theyâre not chasing virality; theyâre manufacturing predictability.
đ Input Volume Builds Intelligence, Not Fatigue
If testing feels inconclusive, itâs not your copy; itâs your chaos. Six lookalikes running overlapping variants teach nothing. One clean campaign teaches everything. Run one ad set, 25 distinct ads.
Tag by hook, visual device, and goal. After 3 days, tier by result, win, hold, fail. Scale the winners. Archive the noise. The cleaner the data flow, the faster the compounding.
đ Testing Is R&D, Not Insurance
Most brands âbudget for testingâ like itâs damage control. Wrong game. Thatâs your venture fund. Youâre investing in 10â20 attempts to find one story that flips CAC and redefines your narrative.
Protecting âdecentâ ads is how brands die in slow motion. If itâs not growing, itâs decaying. The system isnât there to make safe bets, itâs there to accelerate breakthroughs.
đ§ What This Unlocks Before BFCM
Skip 10 days of lag with pre-tagged hooks and outcomes. Launch and scale 3â4Ă faster with no creative fatigue.
Turn testing into a profitable flywheel, not a graveyard. Spin out 2â3 new winners per week, and build data that improves every PDP, email, and retention lever downstream.
Why It Matters
Black Friday isnât about who spends the most; itâs who learns fastest. Meta, TikTok, and Google donât reward budgets. They reward signal clarity.
Testing isnât gambling anymore. Itâs manufacturing, and the factory with the cleanest system wins.
đ Ad Market Shakeup: CPC, CAC, and ROAS at a Glance
Northbeamâs Media Buyer Index (Oct 15â21, 2025) reveals how ad costs, conversions, and returns are shifting across major platforms. While search and video hold steady on efficiency, social channels continue to feel volatility across acquisition and spend.
The Breakdown:
1. CPC â Search Gets Cheaper, Social Tightens - Click costs fell across Google (-5.88%), YouTube (-7.04%), and Pinterest (-7.98%), signaling improved ad efficiency. TikTok (+4.24%) and Microsoft (+4.28%) saw cost hikes as competition rose. Lower CPCs in search and video channels indicate leaner performance potential across intent-driven ecosystems.
2. CAC â Costs Rise Where Attention Is Fastest - Customer acquisition costs stayed stable on Google (-0.48%) and YouTube (-0.97%), but jumped sharply on TikTok (+4.48%), Microsoft (+10.89%), and Snapchat (+23.84%). The spike highlights how short-form and attention-heavy formats are struggling to convert.
3. ROAS â YouTube Pulls Ahead While Others Lag - YouTube (+8.93%) led on ROAS, reflecting strong performance from video-first campaigns. Meta saw slight growth (+1.66%), while TikTok (-6.48%) and Pinterest (-8.80%) slipped. High-ROAS platforms are clearly clustering around content ecosystems where engagement depth meets purchase intent.
Budgets are shifting toward efficient ecosystems, with Google Ads (+10.63%), Microsoft (+7.26%), and Pinterest (+7.83%) gaining ground as Meta and Google hold dominance. The ad landscape is rebalancing toward search and video channels, showing stronger ROAS and lower CPCs. As conversion costs rise on social, efficiency, not scale, is becoming the new performance frontier.
đ Ad of the Day
What Works:
1. Real-World Application Shot - The top visual shows an actual moment of application, no studio polish, just genuine care. It builds trust through relatability, not perfection. Show the moment of use, not just the product, authenticity converts better than aesthetics.
2. Packaging as Proof - The product box is held clearly yet casually, it feels integrated into life, not forced as a promo. Treat packaging as a silent spokesperson, placement should signal trust, not transaction.
2. Purpose-Led Copy That Feels Confident - âPlant Powered Protection that works.â blends emotional reassurance with functional proof in one line. Itâs both soft and assertive. Fuse emotional values (âplant poweredâ) with performance assurance (âthat worksâ) to win both heart and logic.
This ad thrives on emotional clarity and natural storytelling. It doesnât shout about being âeco-friendlyâ it shows it through tone, touch, and trust, proving that the most believable ads feel lived-in, not designed.
Advertise with Us
Wanna put out your message in front of over 50,000 best marketers and decision makers?
We are concerned about everything DTC and its winning strategies. If you liked what you read, why not join the 50k+ marketers from 13k+ DTC brands who have already subscribed? Just follow this.
At ScaleUP, we care about our readers and want to provide the best possible experience. That's why we always look for ways to improve our content and connect with our audience. If you'd like to stay in touch, be sure to follow us EVERYWHEREđĽ°
Thanks for your support :) We'll be back again with more such content đĽł